Wednesday, 9 November 2005 - 8:00 AM
288-1

Long Term Soil Experiments: Lessons from the past and Prospects for the Future.

Pete Smith1, David Powlson2, Paul Poulton2, Keith Goulding2, and Brian McConkey3. (1) School of Biological Sciences, University of Aberdeen, Cruickshank Building, St Machar Drive, Aberdeen, AB24 3UU, United Kingdom, (2) Rothamsted Research, Agriculture & Environment Div., Rothamsted Research, Harpenden, AL52JQ, United Kingdom, (3) Agriculture & Agri-Food Canada, Agriculture Canada, Box 1030, Swift Current, SK S9H3X2, Canada

Long term soil experiments were set up for reasons very different from those for which they are used to today. They teach us the importance of land use and management history and provide a reality check for our models, which are often calibrated using short term data, but expected to project changes in soil carbon in the long term.

In this paper I review some of the lessons to be learned from long term soil experiments, and existing and new networks of long term experiments, before reviewing some of the novel applications to which they have been put, and some of the drawbacks inherent in long term experiments.

Long term soil experiments have provided many answers that it would not have been possible to obtain from other sources, including vital information on the impacts of land-use change, climate change, pollution, on parameters ranging from soil carbon to net primary production to biodiversity.

They have also been used to evaluate and test models and to test sensitivity and uncertainty of model outputs. Because many experiments were set up many years ago, they have drawbacks, often including lack of replication and few independent samples with to assess statistical power / uncertainty. These potential short-comings are reviewed.

Nevertheless, long term soil experiments potentially now have an important new role in forming benchmark sites as part of integrated national carbon accounting systems; examples are given from Canada. To fulfil this new role, many experiments will need to adapt, but the challenge is a worthy one, giving a new long term future to experiments in a world with increasingly short term priorities.


Back to Symposium---New Horizons from Long-Term Soil Experiments: Interdisciplinary Opportunities to Examine Soil Change
Back to S07 Forest, Range & Wildland Soils

Back to The ASA-CSSA-SSSA International Annual Meetings (November 6-10, 2005)